Free exposure scan. Cleanup plans start at $1 for the first month. Start cleanup →
Home/Blog/Is MyLife Safe?
Back to Blog
Site Review

Is MyLife Safe? The FTC Case and Its Reputation Scores

7 min read

MyLife is a people-search site that displays a "reputation score" on its profiles. In 2020 the FTC and DOJ sued MyLife.com and its CEO over teaser background reports and subscription practices. A court approved a settlement order on December 15, 2021. Here is what the case covered and what you can do about your profile.

Is MyLife Legal?

MyLife operates, but it has a documented regulatory history. The FTC and the Department of Justice sued MyLife.com and its CEO Jeffrey Tinsley in July 2020 (FTC case summary). The complaint alleged that MyLife's "teaser" background reports suggested a searched person might have arrest, criminal or sexual offense records, even when the reports contained none, with the records visible only to paying subscribers.

The FTC alleged that MyLife:

  • Used teaser reports that falsely implied people had criminal or sexual offense records
  • Led some consumers to believe that minor traffic citations were criminal
  • Violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act (accuracy and permissible-use procedures)
  • Did not clearly disclose upfront charges and auto-renewal terms (Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act)
  • Misrepresented its cancellation policies (Telemarketing Sales Rule)

A court approved a stipulated order on December 15, 2021. Per the FTC, Tinsley and MyLife agreed to separate judgments totaling $33.9 million. Tinsley pays $5 million and MyLife's $16 million judgment is partially suspended because it could not pay in full, which the FTC counts as $21 million for consumers. Both are permanently banned from offering products with a negative option feature, and MyLife must run an FCRA compliance monitoring program.

What Information Does MyLife Show?

MyLife profiles combine standard people-search data with its controversial reputation scoring system:

  • Full name, age, and location
  • Current and past home addresses
  • Phone numbers and email addresses
  • A "reputation score" displayed on the profile
  • Background check summary or preview text
  • Known associates and relatives
  • Social media profile links
  • Employment and education information (where available)
  • Property ownership records

The most distinctive element is the reputation score. We have not found a published methodology or an independent check of the scores. Profiles can show up in Google results when someone searches your name, so a score you never asked for may be visible to anyone who looks you up. What shows up varies, so search your own name to see.

Where Does MyLife Get Your Data?

MyLife does not publish a complete source list that we could verify. People-search sites in general draw on public government records (court filings, property records, voter registrations), phone and address directories, and commercially licensed consumer data. Check MyLife's own privacy policy for what it says about its sources.

Is MyLife Safe to Use?

The FTC and DOJ case is the main thing to know. The complaint alleged that teaser reports implied criminal or sexual offense records that the reports did not contain. The settlement order, rather than a court finding after trial, resolved the case.

If you are thinking of subscribing to MyLife, read the current terms and cancellation process first. The complaint alleged that MyLife did not clearly disclose charges and automatic renewal. You do not need a subscription to ask for removal of your profile.

Can MyLife Be Used for Stalking or Harassment?

Any people-search site that lists a home address and phone number can be misused for stalking or harassment. A profile that shows a reputation score or teaser text can also be shared to damage someone's reputation.

If you have a safety concern, check what your profiles show and request removal. See also what people-search sites are.

How to Remove Yourself From MyLife

Use the privacy or opt-out options on MyLife's own site, and see our MyLife opt-out guide for the current steps. A sent request is not a confirmed removal, so check that the profile is gone.

Removing your profile from MyLife does not necessarily remove the Google search result immediately. After the profile is deleted, you can ask Google to refresh or remove the outdated result. For a full walkthrough, see our MyLife opt-out guide.

Related guides

Popular on GhostVault