California Started Fining Data Brokers, Not for Ignoring You
The Delete Act deadline landed on August 1, 2026. In the same month, California's privacy regulator announced fines against two data brokers, LocateSmarter and Cybba, and earlier it had fined ROR Partners. Read what these three brokers were fined for and a pattern shows up: none of the three penalties is for receiving a lawful deletion request and ignoring it. We use our own broker data to show what brokers send back instead.
What August 1 Actually Required
It helps to be precise about the obligation. Under the Delete Act, from August 1, 2026, every registered data broker must:
- Access DROP at least once every 45 days (Civ. Code 1798.99.86).
- Process the deletion requests within 45 days after receiving them, subject to limited exceptions (Civ. Code 1798.99.86).
Failing to delete can draw an administrative fine of $200 for each deletion request for each day the broker fails to delete, plus the agency's reasonable expenses (Civ. Code 1798.99.82). Failing to register carries a separate $200 per day fine (Civ. Code 1798.99.82).
The Fines, in Order
California's privacy regulator announced a dedicated Data Broker Enforcement Strike Force on November 19, 2025, per the CalPrivacy announcement. This is not a full list of its actions. CalPrivacy says it has brought more than a dozen data broker actions in total (CalPrivacy announcement). These are the three we look at here.
| Company | Announced | Amount | What for |
|---|---|---|---|
| ROR Partners, LLC | December 2025 | $56,600 | Operating as an unregistered data broker |
| LocateSmarter, LLC | August 11, 2026 | $116,490 | Failure to register; excessive ID demands to opt out |
| Cybba, Inc. | August 13, 2026 | $52,400 | Failure to register for its 2024 activities |
ROR Partners is a Nevada marketing firm. Per the CalPrivacy announcement, its data covered more than 262 million Americans and it was not registered as a data broker for its 2024 activities. The fine was $56,600 in fines and past-due fees.
LocateSmarter drew the largest penalty and the only one with a second count attached. Per the CalPrivacy announcement, it did not register on time and also required consumers to provide the last four digits of their Social Security number before they could opt out of sales. The agency said this conflicts with the CCPA's data minimization requirements. The order totals $116,490.
Cybba, a Boston-based data broker, was fined for failing to register by the 2025 deadline (CalPrivacy announcement). The decision also requires it to access DROP and process future deletion requests through it.
The Pattern Nobody Is Naming
These three fines are for registration and an opt-out form, not ignored requests
These three actions total about $225,000 in penalties ($56,600, $116,490 and $52,400). None is described as: you received a valid deletion request from a Californian and you did not honour it. The violations are registration failures and, for LocateSmarter, an opt-out form that asked for too much.
This is not a criticism of the agency. Registration is the correct place to start, because registration is the one obligation a regulator can verify from the outside. You compare a list of companies that trade in personal data against a list of companies that filed. The gap is your docket. It is cheap, it is provable, and it establishes that the statute has teeth.
Whether a specific broker actually deleted a specific person's record is a completely different evidentiary problem. The regulator cannot see inside the database. It largely depends on the consumer noticing, and complaining, and being able to describe what happened. That brings us to the part we can measure.
What Brokers Send Back
We run a data removal service. We file deletion demands under the CCPA on behalf of our customers, and broker replies are classified and filed as evidence. Our public broker pages summarize this for brokers with enough data. We state these figures from that data, which was exported on November 13, 2026.
GhostVault broker page data, exported November 13, 2026
- 263 broker pages with enough data to publish a summary
- 11,751 deletion demands sent to those brokers
- 10,865 of those delivered
- 2,127 asked the consumer for something
- 1,061 said they hold no data on the person
- 241 confirmed a deletion in writing
Do not read these as a success rate. Delivered is not deleted, many demands are still inside the response window (the CCPA gives a business 45 days to respond, extendable once by another 45 days if the consumer is notified, per Civ. Code 1798.130), and these figures cover only brokers with enough replies to publish.
The number that is most telling is the shape of the replies. Among the specific requests brokers made of consumers, the most common was to use the broker's own web form, at 1,228 demands across the broker pages. Brokers also asked for signed authorization (575), more identifying details (476), a mailing address (289) and identity verification (255).
"Please Use Our Web Form"
When a broker answers with a request, the largest single category in our data is a pointer to its own web form. The reply is sometimes a courteous paragraph with a link and sometimes a bare autoresponder. The effect is the same: the deletion waits until the person fills in the form.
A broker that answers with a working portal can point to a lawful mechanism. It still requires the human being to go and fill it in, one broker at a time. That is the step a single-request deletion platform is meant to remove.
Why this is invisible to enforcement
A broker that ignores you leaves a trail: an unanswered request or a consumer complaint. A broker that redirects you may leave no complaint, because you were given a link. A deletion that was deferred back to the person who asked for it is harder for a regulator to see.
The Second Thing We See: Identity Walls
The LocateSmarter count (requiring part of a Social Security number to process an opt-out) is a reminder that verification can be a barrier. In our data, brokers ask for signed authorization, more identifying details, a mailing address or identity verification in a large share of the replies that ask for something.
Some verification is legitimate, and the CCPA permits it. The agency's action against LocateSmarter shows the line between verification and unnecessary data collection is being enforced.
What This Means If You Live in California
- Use DROP. It is free. One submission goes to every broker registered with the state, and from August 1 those brokers must access DROP at least once every 45 days.
- Do not assume DROP finished the job. It reaches registered brokers only. The ROR Partners, LocateSmarter and Cybba fines were all for registration failures, so some companies that trade in personal data were not registered.
- Expect the portal redirect, and budget for it. Whether you file yourself or use a service, some brokers will ask you to use their own web form. A service can track which brokers are waiting on you, but it cannot complete a step that only the consumer can complete.
- Keep your evidence. Dated proof of what you asked for, and when, is useful if a broker does not respond.
- Re-check in 90 days. Deletion is not a one-time state. A broker can collect your information again from other sources after it deletes a record, so check periodically.
What We Would Like to See Next
These actions show the agency is willing to enforce the registration requirement. The open question is whether enforcement will reach the behaviour that determines whether anyone's data gets deleted.
Concretely, that would mean an action against a broker that is registered, did receive requests through DROP, and used a portal redirect or an identity wall to run out the 45-day clock. We have not found an announced action of that kind.
Methodology: figures come from GhostVault's broker page data, exported November 13, 2026, covering the broker pages with enough data to publish a summary. "Confirmed in writing" means a broker stated in a reply that the record was deleted. Delivered does not mean deleted. Enforcement details are from the California Privacy Protection Agency's (CalPrivacy) announcements and the California Civil Code sections linked above.